Japanese jingoism won’t help Fukushima

Tags: Op-ed
Japanese jingoism won’t help Fukushima
PAST AND PRESENT: Japanese prime minister Shinzo Abe bows in front an altar for the victims of the 11 March 2011 earthquake and tsunami at the national memorial service in Tokyo on Tuesday
Does Shinzo Abe love soldiers who died during World War II more than Japanese living today?

The question might sound disrespectful. But I can’t help asking it as I survey the placards at anti-government rallies commemorating the third anniversary of the Fukushima earthquake and tsunami, which left almost 20,000 people dead or missing and erased entire towns. “Abe is AWOL,” says one. Another: “Nationalism doesn’t create jobs!” The one that moved me most was carried by a 30-something mother wearing a “No nukes” T-shirt: “My kids still can’t play outside.”

After 1,095 days, untold billions of dollars of public expenditures and countless pledges to accelerate rebuilding efforts, radiation is still leaking at Fukushima. Only 3.4 per cent of planned public-housing projects are close to being completed. A whole generation of kids in the northeast Tohoku region are tested regularly for thyroid cancer. They can barely remember anything but temporary housing, and must wonder if outdoor playgrounds really exist.

If prime minister Abe spent even a fraction of his time helping tsunami-devastated towns and Fukushima’s nuclear refugees instead of fighting with Japan’s neighbours over history, Tohoku citizens would be much better off. Unfair criticism? Abe’s image-makers certainly think so; they play up his 13 visits to Tohoku since December 2012.

Face it: These obligatory jaunts up north are nothing more than disaster porn. This has become an unfortunate part of the global news playbook. Celebrity journalists parachute into danger zones, stand amid rubble and corpses, and repeat the words “unspeakable tragedy” in an endless 24-hour loop. Politicians are hardly less cynical. Photo ops with local government officials, displaced families and children grieving for lost classmates may score big points down in Tokyo. But they do nothing on the ground.

The official reason for the glacial pace of reconstruction is a shortage of labour, building materials and bids from the construction industry. The real problem is that the Tokyo political establishment has largely forgotten about Tohoku.

Although Abe inherited this problem, his blinders seem to be growing in size with each passing month. His direct predecessor Yoshihiko Noda also made frequent visits to Tohoku, as did Naoto Kan before him. How is it that a nation known for hyper efficiency, one that surged from the ashes of World War II to threaten US economic dominance for a time, could fail at so obvious a task? Chronic inattention.

Daunting as it is, the scale of the problem is no longer an acceptable excuse for abandoning 1,00,000 people in temporary accommodations that are cold, spartan and devoid of privacy. Let’s take the government at its word that it’s having difficulty in attracting builders — just offer them more money. Abe’s team claims there’s a labour shortage, something they should’ve considered before lobbying for the 2020 Olympics. Why not import 10,000 construction workers from elsewhere in Asia? The ends would justify the means in a nation that suffers from a shrinking workforce. And the jolt provided by big new projects could give the economy a welcome boost.

Yes, Japan is bureaucratic, and these things take time. But Abe, who enjoys a majority in both houses of parliament, has had 62 weeks to get his cabinet members, lawmakers and reconstruction officials into a room together to cut red tape and demand action; 440 days to ease the pain of those still reeling from what Japanese call “3/11”; 10,560 hours to demand that the Liberal Democratic Party’s construction-industry cronies, who have made huge profits clearing away debris, do more to rebuild and decontaminate areas around Fukushima to acceptable levels.

Abe had enough time to visit Buenos Aires to reassure the International Olympic Committee that Fukushima’s radiation was “under control.” His schedule has included trips to Turkey and India to sell nuclear technology on behalf of Japan Inc. The prime minister’s itinerary takes him to places as diverse as Ireland, Malaysia, Mozambique, Oman and even Wall Street to convey that “Japan is back” and ready to be assume a renewed leadership role in Asia.

But the government’s inability to handle its crisis at home belies its global ambitions. Time that should be allotted to sorting out Tohoku is squandered debating World War II atrocities, teaching “patriotism” to school kids, staffing national broadcaster NHK with like-minded conservatives and defending a prime ministerial visit to Tokyo’s Yasukuni Shrine, where the souls of 14 class-A war criminals are enshrined among other war dead. Abe seems to believe Japan has been victimised by history. So why is he ignoring Japan’s present victims?

For a leader who cloaks his most controversial policies in an aura of patriotism, Abe has a strange way of showing his love for Japan. An area that’s home to more than nine million Japanese, could use more affection — and attention —from Tokyo. Like myself, Tohoku residents could be excused for wondering why a bunch of dead soldiers appear to hold more fascination for Abe than they do.


(William Pesek is a Bloomberg View columnist based in Tokyo and writes on economics, markets and politics throughout the Asia-Pacific region.)

Post new comment

E-mail ID will not be published
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


  • Kejriwal will do well to ignore the bickering and get on with work

    Psychologists explain implosion as a form of behaviour involving intensive recollection and review of anxiety-producing situations or events in an att


Stay informed on our latest news!


Sarthak Raychaudhuri

vice-president, HR, Asia South Whirlpool of India

GV Nageswara Rao

MD & CEO, IDBI Federal Life

Timothy Moe

Goldman Sachs

Today's Columns

Simon J Evenett

Are you keeping an eye on BRIC reforms?

When the history of state action during the crisis era ...

Kuruvilla Pandikattu SJ

How do we explain pain and passion?

The holy week that the christians celebrate this week recalls ...

Shona Adhikari

Anjolie Ela Menon, the storyteller, is back

Anjolie Ela Menon, one of India’s most celebrated artists, is ...


William D. Green

Chairman & CEO, Accenture