Cultural fanaticism that surrounds us

Tags: Op-ed
Cultural fanaticism that surrounds us
ONE AND ALL: Indian schoolgirls wear masks of Malala Yousufzai who was shot by a Taliban gunman in Pakistan, in New Delhi on February 2. Malala has been nominated for this year’s Nobel Peace Prize
Malala You­sa­fzai is a Pakistani girl of Pushtun ethnicity. She is barely 15 years old. She is the youngest nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize in history. I hope she has the distinction of being the youngest recipient of the prize.

Malala authored a blog un­der a nom de plume for the BBC, describing life under the Taliban rule, their game plan to take control of the Swat valley and her own views on promoting education for girls. She has been an evangelist of education for girls in tribal Pakistan.

On October 9, 2012, You­safzai was shot in the head and neck in an assassination attempt by Taliban gunmen, while she was returning home on a school bus. She remained unconscious for a few days. Thereafter, she was transferred from Pakistan to a hospital in Birmingham, UK for treatment.

On February 8, she was released from the hospital and she said, “Today you can see that I am alive. It’s just because of the prayers of people. Because all people — men, wo­men, children — all of them have prayed for me. And because of all these prayers, god has given me this new life, a second life. And I want to serve. I want to serve the people. I want every girl, every child, to be educated.” What a brave girl!

Meanwhile, Ehsanullah Eh­san, chief spokesman for the Pakistani Taliban, who claimed responsibility for the attack, said that Yousafzai, “is the symbol of the infidels and obscenity,” adding that if she survived, they would target her again.

Winston Churchill had famously said, “A fanatic is one who can’t change his mind and won’t change the subject.” Cultural intolerance is turning fanatical, violent and blind. In a democracy like ours, we must have tolerance, pluralism, argumentation and discord. Th­ere can be no democracy if debates are settled with guns, discord lands you in prison and dissent ruins your career or even destroys your life. Although there is some debate on whether Voltaire actually uttered these words (or it was the work of his biographer), they nevertheless capture the essence of democratic discourse; “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”

Far too often, fanatics of all hues and colours are combining forces to stifle discourse and the expression of artists, authors and philosophers. Kamal Hasaan, the veteran Tamil actor has written, directed and co-produced a film called Viswaroopam. The film’s Tamil version was given a U/A (parental guidance) certificate by the Central Board of Film Certification with minor cuts, while the Hindi version Vishwaroop got an A (adults only) certificate with no cuts. It is a spy thriller film.

Despite the censor board’s certificates, Hasaan faced all kinds of objections from diverse groups. The Hindu Makkal Katchi party demanded the change from its current Sanskrit title to a purely Tamil one. Some Muslim groups in Tamil Nadu raised their objections that the film would hurt Muslim sentiments. Kamal Hasaan said in anguish that he would leave Tamil Nadu and India for good if the “cultural terrorism” went unabated. Hasaan finally agreed to mute five scenes and film was released in his home state to full houses.

M F Hussain, one of the finest Indian painters left India in 2006. He was awarded a Padma Bhushan (1973) and a Padma Vibhushan (1991). In 1998, Husain’s house was attacked by fanatic groups like the Bajrang Dal and his art works were vandalised.

He became the target of cultural fanatics and finally left India and lived in self-exile. He became a Qatari citizen in 2010 and died and was buried in London. No terrorist or fanatic actually killed him, but many of them enjoyed reading his obituary.

Professor Ashish Nandy, who has always been a little eccentric, propounded a bi­zarre theory on corruption as a route for upward social mobility at a seminar. Wrong choice of words and wrong examples as the Supreme Court judges pointed out. But he was going to be arrested for that? Did he not have a right to be wrong? Can he not express a different opinion? The Su­preme Court made a good call and stayed his arrest.

Salman Rushdie has outlived his Iranian fatwa, alright. But he is having trouble with the country of his birth. The scared authorities are worried about a run on their vote banks if Rushdie comes calling. He was unable to attend the Jaipur Literary Festival and the International Kolkata Book Fair because the authorities would not allow him entry to the respective cities. Amartya Sen raised his voice against not allowing Rushdie to come to Kolkata and said, “Anything that makes the Indian constructive argumentative tradition more militant — (so) that people have the right (to be offended) and therefore, you cannot say some things — becomes a limitation because it restricts the conversation.”

Fanaticism cannot alter facts nor can it turn the clock back. When Galileo was be­ing forced by the Church at an inquisition to recant his belief that the earth revolved aro­und the sun, he uttered those immortal words, “Epp­ur si mu­ove” (Yet it moves). And indeed it moves and revolves even today. The fanatic may have stifled Galileo’s voice. But Galileo is having the last laugh.

(The writer is managing director of Deloitte Consulting, India. These are his personal views)


  • Annual reports make sense only if accountable governance is in place

    It’s a sign of a lack of imagination to expect an annual report by a party in power to pull out some impressive performance given the complex nature


Stay informed on our latest news!


Amita Sharma

Political rhetoric makes for counter poetry

Poetic flourishes flavour politics. Ghalib and Hafez flowed profusely to ...

Zehra Naqvi

Watch your words, for they can kill

You must’ve heard the ph­rase ‘if looks could kill’. Ever ...

Dharmendra Khandal

Biodiversity day has come and gone. Yet again

Every year on May 22, world celebrates international biodiversity day. ...


William D. Green

Chairman & CEO, Accenture