Understand competitive advantage of distribution strategy
Mar 10 2014
Rather than selling primarily to end-users through channels playing largely a logistics role, B2B marketeers typically sell their products to firms that in turn create other products for sales further down the value chain. Each combination of primary buyer and downstream secondary buyer creates a different customer chain. In developing marketing strategies, one of our first critical questions is the price sensitivity of a target market segment. Does competitive advantage lie in cost leadership, or does it take value marketing — a bundle of services and intangible benefits enhancing the product — to win the business? Finding the answer that should drive your marketing plan is straightforward when the customer chain is simple, and the sole customer type is a direct buyer or a customer purchasing through a passive channel.
But most business markets do not work that way. The primary buyer responds to its set of value drivers and in turn must cater to downstream buyers’ preferences. Part of your competitive advantage, then, becomes your contribution to your direct customer’s marketing success downstream. For instance, does your product help your primary customer cut costs and thus better appeal to price-sensitive downstream buyers? Or do you provide a high-quality input to your primary customers’ products that contributes to a stronger value-added proposition down the value chain? The popularity of ingredient business branding, for example, reflects the industry’s growing recognition of brands’ ability to influence downstream demand and make a product indispensable to primary customers.
The simple customer-chain model begins to fail us as a strategic tool at this point, however, when primary and secondary buyers respond to significantly different benefits. In a two-stage customer chain, how do you protect your downstream positioning as a value-added producer when your primary customer buys primarily on price? Or if your value sell to the primary customer will not impress the price-driven secondary customer?
At this point, it can be useful to analyse your customer chains according to a useful framework that recommends specific strategies depending on the customer chain environment in which you are selling. As the Blue Canyon framework makes clear, marketing strategies and the need to build a B2B brand are not simply a matter of throwing advertising money at the market. The basic framework specifies four B2B market environments based on the price-sensitivity of primary and secondary customers.
When both primary and secondary customers buy mainly on price factors, promote your ability to reduce their costs. Similarly straightforward competitive advantage — when both primary and secondary customers buy mainly on non-price factors, — depends on building relationships throughout the value chain, emphasising service, product enhancements and the contributions of your processes and systems to customers’ business success. When the primary buyer responds to value-added and other non-price appeals, but the secondary customer is a price buyer, your job is to provide the systems and product enhancements that help the primary customer cut its price to secondary customers.
When the primary buyer is price-driven, but the secondary customer seeks value enhancements and other non-price reasons to buy, promote cost-justifiable product enhancements that improve the primary buyer’s value-added appeal to the secondary buyer. In this environment, ingredient brand positioning strategies that assist OEM primary customers — such as the “Intel Inside” approach to personal computer OEMs and end-users — can be particularly potent.
Mapping the customer chains that create distinct market segments, then refining Blue Canyon’s broad strategic model using the specifics of individual segments, have helped firms spot opportunities they missed or identify shortcomings in their marketing plans. One industrial tool manufacturer relying on a top-shelf image and pricing to match, for example, repeatedly failed to penetrate a new distribution channel that it thought would be a natural expansion. Researching the price and value drivers of its current and hoped-for segments, and applying Blue Canyon’s customer chain analysis, revealed why the manufacturer’s premier brand should not even try to compete in the relatively price-sensitive market segment it had hoped to capture. zz
(The writer is CEO and MD